3D Printer FYI

Choosing Your First Filament: PLA vs. PETG vs. ABS

—

by

3dprinter.fyi
in ,

When you’re just getting started with 3D printing, one of the first major decisions you’ll make—beyond choosing a printer—is deciding which filament to use. Three popular (and relatively beginner-friendly) options are PLA, PETG, and ABS. Each material has its own unique characteristics, pros, cons, and best use-cases. Understanding these will help you pick the filament that matches your project goals and skill level.

1. PLA (Polylactic Acid)

Overview
PLA is often considered the go-to filament for beginners. Made from renewable resources like corn starch, it’s biodegradable under certain conditions, which adds an eco-friendly edge. More importantly, it’s one of the easiest filaments to print with because of its relatively low printing temperature and minimal warping.

Pros

  • Easy to Print: Requires lower temperatures (usually around 190°C–210°C) and often prints well without a heated bed (though a 60°C bed is recommended).
  • Low Warping: Adheres well to the build surface, minimizing curling at the edges.
  • Non-Toxic Odor: Emits a mild, sweet smell when printing.
  • Good Surface Finish: Produces smooth, shiny prints with less stringing compared to some other materials.

Cons

  • Lower Heat Resistance: PLA parts can deform if left in a hot car or near a heat source.
  • Brittle: Can snap under sudden stress; not ideal for functional parts requiring high impact resistance.
  • Limited Outdoor Durability: Prolonged exposure to sunlight and moisture can degrade PLA.

Best Use-Cases

  • Decorative models, prototypes, and household items.
  • Educational or quick prototyping scenarios.
  • When easy printing and surface finish are higher priorities than strength.

2. PETG (Polyethylene Terephthalate Glycol)

Overview
PETG has gained massive popularity as a strong, durable alternative that’s still reasonably beginner-friendly. It’s less brittle than PLA and offers better heat resistance while avoiding some of the difficulties associated with ABS.

Pros

  • Strong & Flexible: Strikes a balance between rigidity and flexibility; prints often can withstand moderate impact.
  • Good Layer Adhesion: Tends to bond well between layers, leading to sturdier final parts.
  • Relatively Low Warping: More stable than ABS, though slightly more challenging than PLA.
  • Chemical Resistance: Resistant to water and some chemicals, making it suitable for functional applications.

Cons

  • Stringing & Oozing: PETG can be stringy if retraction settings aren’t fine-tuned.
  • Higher Printing Temp: Typically prints around 220°C–250°C, so you’ll need a printer that can safely reach these temperatures.
  • Bed Adhesion: Can stick too well to certain surfaces (like glass), making prints harder to remove.

Best Use-Cases

  • Functional parts, mechanical components, or items exposed to moderate heat.
  • Outdoor applications where a bit of weather resistance is needed.
  • Projects that require a balance between flexibility and durability.

Which Filament Should You Choose First?

  • If You’re Brand-New to 3D Printing: PLA is almost always the recommended starting point. It’s forgiving, requires minimal setup, and prints beautifully on nearly all entry-level machines.
  • If You Need a Little More Durability but Can Handle Some Tuning: PETG is a great second step. It offers superior strength and heat resistance to PLA without being as finicky as ABS.
  • If You’re Focused on Functional, High-Strength Parts and Don’t Mind the Challenges: ABS might be worth trying if you have a printer with an enclosure (or can add one), good ventilation, and the patience to dial in your settings.

Practical Tips

  1. Check Printer Specs
    • Ensure your printer can reach the temperatures needed for the filament you choose.
    • A heated bed is highly recommended for PETG and ABS to prevent warping.
  2. Ventilation
    • For PLA, a simple, well-ventilated room is usually fine.
    • For ABS, consider an enclosure to maintain temperature and filter out fumes.
  3. Bed Surface
    • PLA: Works well on surfaces like blue painter’s tape, PEI sheets, or a glass bed with some glue stick.
    • PETG: A PEI or glass bed is good, but be careful with adhesion so parts aren’t overly stuck.
    • ABS: Often needs a dedicated surface like Kapton tape, ABS slurry, or a specialized build plate that handles high temps.
  4. Storage
    • All filaments can absorb moisture over time. Store in airtight containers with desiccant, especially in humid climates.
    • PETG and ABS can be more prone to moisture issues, leading to stringing and under-extrusion if filament is wet.

Conclusion

Starting with the right filament can greatly increase your early success in 3D printing. PLA offers the easiest path, PETG provides a balance of toughness and relative ease of use, and ABS delivers strong, heat-resistant parts—at the cost of more complexity. Consider your project goals, printer capabilities, and willingness to tinker. With these factors in mind, you’ll make a well-informed decision that sets you on a smooth path toward creating awesome 3D prints.

Happy printing!